Hoagie Haven • 1974

Princeton students have stumbled into Hoagie Haven since 1974 craving sandwiches that defy logic—mozzarella sticks, fries, and chicken fingers piled into fresh Italian People's Bakery rolls. The Maltabes family has run the Nassau Street shop since 2005, slinging legendary creations like the Sanchez and the Phat Lady that transform a late-night craving into a rite of passage. Order the Phat Lady if you're hungry enough to handle bacon, cheese, and pure excess on a single roll.