Kinchley's Tavern • 1947

This Ramsey institution serves Bergen County's most celebrated ultra-thin crust bar pie, prepared according to the original Kinchley family recipe that's remained unchanged for nearly 90 years. The wood-paneled tavern with red-checkered tablecloths and vintage Lionel trains on display draws loyal crowds who come for crackling-crisp pizza topped with tangy sauce and quality cheese, plus Monday's all-you-can-eat ravioli and Tuesday's linguine with meatballs. You'll know you've arrived when you spot the iconic Clydesdale horse perched on the roof—bring cash and expect a wait, because this cash-only legend is worth every minute.