Reo Diner • 1935

Since the Great Depression, this Central Jersey landmark has fed hungry crowds everything from towering Belgian waffles to its signature Fat Cats—indulgent hoagie rolls stuffed with mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders, and marinara sauce. Known as the Gem of Woodbridge, the diner's celebrity wall features photos of Robert DeNiro, Joe Pesci, and other bold-faced names who've stopped in over the decades. House-made desserts fill the bakery case, from fresh pies to pastries that draw regulars back for one more slice.