El Parador Cafe • 1959

The oldest Mexican restaurant in New York City, El Parador Cafe has been shaking legendary margaritas and serving authentic Mexican cuisine in Murray Hill since 1959. Founded over six decades ago, it earned praise from The New York Times and The New York Press for its ceviche and tequila-forward cocktails. The timeless dining room still draws crowds for dishes that honor both traditional recipes and contemporary flavors.