Sonny's Bagels • 1971

Hand-rolled bagels have anchored this South Orange shop since 1971, drawing crowds for their chewy crust and tender crumb. Sonny's sources smoked fish from the same legendary New York purveyors that supply Russ & Daughters and Zabar's, pairing them with house-made specialty cream cheeses. The bagels still emerge warm from the oven throughout the morning, worth timing your visit right.