The Original Pizza of Avenue L, INC • 1969

For over five decades, this family-run Canarsie pizzeria has turned out classic New York slices heavy on cheese with a well-done undercarriage. The Sicilian pies and garlic knots draw steady crowds, while specialty slices like Buffalo chicken and chicken Caesar keep the menu evolving. Cash only, always fresh, never disappointing the locals who've made it a fixture since 1969.