Canoe Hill

Canoe Hill brings a quiet kind of cool to our Cozy Map, and to Millbrook as well, where it's located. The menu shifts often, highlighting local ingredients without the usual farm-to-table clichés. Oysters and cocktails keep the bar humming, while the dining room – anchored by a wood stove – delivers polished comfort with zero pretense. This was a reader recommendation, and I couldn't agree more. Comfy Key: Dining • Cocktails • Comfort Food • Farm To Table • Wine • Escape Brooklyn-Approved Double Cozy Verified