50 Delicious South Jersey Pizza Spots on the Map

Made here. Loved everywhere! A perfectly imperfect list of 50 of our favorite south jersey pizza spots for Fall 2024, visualized on the map. Have a suggestion? Visit our SJlist community to recommend the one pizza place you can't live without, and we just may add it to the map! :) Special thanks to the many generous contributions from the fun foodies who make the SJFS FB community a fantastic resource for local pizza lovers of all shapes and sizes - link to the group in the shout out section below.

Pizza We Love

in absolutely NO particular order.

Tony Boloney's

Known for their creative and delicious pizzas, Tony Boloney's is a top-rated pizza spot in Atlantic City.

Carluccio's Coal Fired Pizza

Experience delicious coal-fired pizza at Carluccio's, known for their unique and flavorful pies.

Back Door Pizza

Who doesn't love a pizza with a little bit of mystery? Delicious and makes me feel a little bit like I'm working undercover, rather than eating pizza. (pro tip - my therapist said I can do both, although preferably not in public the same time as I'm a bit of a messy eater)

Zorro's Pizza

Zorro's has a special place in my heart for being the very first place I was introduced to the now ubiquitous "Grandma" pizza - which in my personal journey as a human being, was like a small slice of previously undiscovered universe opened up and revealed itself to me - and I got a peek at what lied on the other side of the divide. Notice the intentional use of "slice" in the universe, and you'll understand that while pizza is my first love, I'm also a world class poet in my free time. You're welcome.

Lillo's Tomato Pies

Lilo's is super popular, super delicious and a big reason why my 2024 body is super sized

Healthy Garden & Gourmet Pizza

Love their Grandma Pizza! (as our Credit Card statement reminds me every month)

Cacia's Bakery - Cherry Hill

The two questions i get asked most often are 1. How do you manage to stay so damn sexy in middle age and 2. What is your favorite low cost Tomato 🍅 Pie for a delicious daily late night snack? Okay, the truth is, nobody asks me #1. Which hurts my feelings. It would take like 2 minutes and i’d do the same for you. (the answer by the way, is lots of polyphenols, which occur naturally in tomatoe pie found in the wild, a positive, "can do" attitude and absolutely no day drinking other than weekends, federal holidays, Sukkot, Eagles season and the occasional Tuesday mid morning brunch with black out shades and some gentle sobbing for the natural exfoliation and pore irrigation) #2. Cacias tomato 🍅 pie for the win homies.

sjlist.com

Villa Russo Pizzeria

Love Villa Russo's Pizza

Ventura's Offshore Cafe

Enjoy delicious pizza at Ventura's Offshore Cafe in Northfield.

Preps Pizzeria & Dairy Bar

Love Prep's Pizza

Bricco Coal Fired Pizza

Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies

Lucky Bones Pizza Cape May

Enjoy delicious pizza with a view in Cape May at Lucky Bones Pizza.

La Tentacion Pizza & Mexican Grill

"The pizza was fantastic. Crust was perfect, better than a lot of pizza shops in the area, imo. And the toppings? Amazing. We got a Birria Pizza (complete with consommé) and a Tijuana Pizza (gouda, chorizo, caramelized onions and pickled jalapeños.)"

Luigi's Family Restaurant

Delicious Nonna pizza!

Vero Pizzeria by Antimo Lamberti

"Seriously the best!" "Can't wait to come back!" "Best Pizza in NJ!"

Piccini

A charming eatery in Ocean City serving award-winning pizza, pasta, and other Italian dishes. Open year-round for lunch and dinner, with a variety of options including over 30 unique pizza pies, delicious pasta dishes, and fresh salads. Catering services available.